The Definition of the Commerce of Immovable Property Under Tax Law
Introduction
In tax law, the concept of the commerce of immovable property is of great importance for determining the applicability of tax exemptions that may come into play under certain conditions, particularly in the sale of immovable property. It is observed that the boundaries of “commerce of immovable property” are ambiguous in terms of tax law, based on the explanations included in the explanatory notes of the relevant provisions of the Corporate Income Tax Law No. 5520 (“CITL”) and the Value Added Tax Law No. 3065 (“VATL”), as well as the private rulings issued in relation to the subject. Therefore, to make an assessment on the matter, it is of importance to examine the decisions rendered by the Council of State. Within this framework, this article will briefly address the VATL regulations regarding the subject and subsequently examine two different decisions rendered by the Council of State in relation thereto.
Value Added Tax Exemption
The former and current versions of the VAT exemption applicable to the sale of immovable property as set forth under Article 17/4-r of the VATL may be summarized in general terms within the scope of the table below:
Sales Before 15.07.2023
Under the previous regulation, the sale of immovable property that had been held in the assets of corporations for at least two full years was exempt from VAT. This exemption provided a significant tax advantage by reducing the VAT burden on immovable property sales carried out outside the scope of commercial activity. Under the current regime as well, the sale of immovable property that was included in the assets of corporations prior to 15.07.2023, provided that the relevant conditions are met, is exempt from VAT.
Sales After 15.07.2023
With Article 7 of Law No. 7456 on the Introduction of an Additional Motor Vehicle Tax for the Compensation of Economic Losses Caused by the Earthquakes Occurring on 06.02.2023 and on the Amendment of Certain Laws and Decree Law No. 375 (“Law No. 7456”), the exemption set forth under Article 17/4-r of the VAT Law has been abolished. Accordingly, the VAT exemption provision does not apply to the sale of immovable property recorded in the assets of corporations after 15.07.2023.
This exemption is available only to taxpayers who are not engaged in the commerce of immovable property. For the exemption to apply:
- The immovable property should have been recorded in the company's assets before 15.07.2023.
- The immovable property should have been held in the company’s assets for at least two years.
- The taxpayer should not be engaged in the commerce of immovable property.
The Council of State Decisions on the Commerce of Immovable Property
Although no detailed definition of the commerce of immovable property is provided in the legislation, the criteria of this concept have been delineated through the decisions of the Council of State. Accordingly, in practice, it is considered beneficial for taxpayers to determine whether they may benefit from the exemptions in line with these criteria and to follow the current views of the Council of State.
1- The Decision of the 9th Chamber of the Council of State dated 15.09.2022 and numbered Case No: 2020/909 Decision No: 2022/3926
In the case subject to this Decision[1] , the Plaintiff Company sold 17 shops and 1 restaurant located in the arcade beneath the hotel building, which had been recorded in its assets for many years and constituted integral parts of the hotel; the Plaintiff argued that these sales were within the scope of the exemption set forth under the VATL. The relevant shops and restaurants were, following the disposal of the hotel through enforcement proceedings, first leased and subsequently sold to the purchaser of the hotel. The tax administration claimed that the company was engaged in the commerce of immovable property. The court of first instance concluded that the immovable properties were continuously leased for the purpose of generating rental income and thus that the Plaintiff Company was engaged in immovable property trading; accordingly, it held that the sales were not within the scope of the VAT exemption.
The regional administrative court ruled to set aside the decision of the court of first instance, to uphold the action, and to annul the penalty-assessed tax assessment.
The Council of State found the decision of the regional administrative court to be following procedural and substantive law and, in favor of the taxpayer, rejected the appeal. The evaluation criteria stated in the reasoning of the regional administrative court decision, which the Council of State also found to be in accordance with the substantive and procedure law, are as follows:
- Purpose of Acquisition: The immovable properties were acquired not for commercial sale but as part of the hotel business.
- Nature of Leasing: The properties were leased out due to financial necessity following the hotel’s sale. Leasing was not part of the company’s core business.
- Continuity and Independence: Considering the definition of commercial enterprise in Article 11 of the Turkish Commercial Code, it has been determined that the plaintiff does not carry out continuous and independent activities in the field of immovable property rental or commerce.
- Nature of the Acquirer: The transfer of the immovable properties to the purchaser of the hotel building further demonstrated that no commercial trading purpose existed.
Thus, the company was not considered to be engaged in the commerce of immovable property.
2- The Decision of the 4th Chamber of the Council of State dated 20.06.2022 and numbered Case No: 2018/2938, Decision No: 2022/4208
In the case subject to this Decision[2] , the activity of “commerce of immovable property” was again examined by the Council of State when conducting an assessment specifically regarding the exception under Article 5/1-e of the CITL.
The Council of State considered the following criteria when evaluating the specific case:
- Existence of a Commercial Organization: If immovable property purchases and sales are conducted within a commercial structure, they constitute commercial activity.
- Continuity: The continued nature of transactions is decisive even if the organization is not clearly structured.
- Number of Transactions: The purchase and sale of more than one immovable property within the same year or in successive years, as well as the sale of many separate independent units registered at the land registry, indicate continuity in immovable property sales and demonstrate the existence of an intention to engage in immovable property trading. Indeed, in the concrete case, 240 immovable property sale invoices were issued.
- Intention to Generate Profit: The intention to profit is presumed; the burden of proof lies with the taxpayer. Here, 97.68% of the company’s revenue originated from immovable property sales. The Plaintiff Company has not presented any evidence to the contrary.
- Articles of Association and Trade Registry Records: The company’s incorporation documents indicated that its activities included construction and immovable property-related operations.
Thus, the company was engaged in the commerce of immovable property.
Conclusion
The Council of State adopts a multifaceted approach in assessing whether taxpayers are engaged in the commerce of immovable property. Therefore, the applicability of the exemption provisions is determined by considering the property's connection to the activity, the number of the transactions, commercial organization, and other factors together. This approach supports both the proper use of tax incentives and legal certainty for taxpayers.
- The Decision of the 9th Chamber of the Council of State dated 15.09.2022 and numbered Case No: 2020/909 Decision No: 2022/3926
- The Decision of the 4th Chamber of the Council of State dated 20.06.2022 and numbered Case No: 2018/2938, Decision No: 2022/4208
All rights of this article are reserved. This article may not be used, reproduced, copied, published, distributed, or otherwise disseminated without quotation or Erdem & Erdem Law Firm's written consent. Any content created without citing the resource or Erdem & Erdem Law Firm’s written consent is regularly tracked, and legal action will be taken in case of violation.
Other Contents
Venture capital is defined as investing in areas where no one has previously dared to invest . In the guideline prepared by the Capital Markets Board (“CMB”), which has the authority to regulate and supervise the capital markets, venture capital is expressed as a form of financing that enables dynamic and creative...
The digitalization process in Turkish commercial life has gained momentum with the widespread adoption of practices that enable commercial ledgers to be kept electronically. In this context, the Communiqué on the Keeping of Non-Accounting Commercial Ledgers of Enterprises in Electronic Form (“Communiqué”)...
The share buyback by a joint stock company is regulated under Articles 379 to 389 of the Turkish Commercial Code No. 6102 (“TCC”). However, in cases where the company subsequently sells these repurchased shares, there is no specific provision in the tax legislation addressing whether the “participation exemption...
Through Articles 4, 33 and 34 of Law No. 7524 on the Amendment of Tax Laws and Certain Laws and Decree-Law No. 375 ("Law No. 7524"), by adding subparagraphs to Article 94 of the Income Tax Law No. 193 and Articles 15 and 30 of the Corporate Tax Law No. 5520, payments made by intermediary...
As a general rule, under Article 80 of the Repetitive Income Tax Law No. 193 ("ITL"), capital gains derived from the disposal of securities, except for exemptions, are subject to income tax as capital appreciation gains...
Article 2 of Law No. 7524 on the Amendment of Tax Laws and Certain Laws and Decree-Law No. 375 ("Law No. 7524") and the income tax exemption for the benefits provided to employees by issuing share certificates, which is regulated under Article 17 of Income Tax Law No. 193 ("ITL"), entered into force as of...
While tax systems introduce general regulations to prevent the abuse of laws, special regulations are introduced as tax security institutions within the scope of tax laws for situations where general regulations do not fulfill the expected function in practice...
It is known that legislative amendments have been made for the acquisition of Turkish citizenship by foreigners within the scope of the Turkish Citizenship Law No. 5901 in order to encourage the sale of residences and workplaces to foreigners...
Through its decision dated 30 November 2023 and No. E. 2023/105 K. 2023/208 ("Decision"), the Constitutional Court of the Republic of Türkiye ("Constitutional Court") annulled the regulation stating that inflation adjustment will not be made for 2021 as stipulated under Provisional Article 33 of Turkish Tax...
Law No. 7456 on Additional Motor Vehicle Tax for Compensation of Economic Losses Caused by the Earthquake on 6/2/2023 and on Amendments to Certain Laws and Decree-Law No. 375 (“Law No. 7456”) was published in the Official Gazette dated 15.07.2023 and No. 32249. Law No. 7456 introduced significant...
In order to determine the procedures and principles regarding the implementation of certain articles of the Misdemeanor Law No. 5326 (“Law”), which is the general procedural law for administrative fines, the Ministry of Treasury and Finance (“Revenue Administration”) has published the General...
Through Article 20 of Law No. 7440 on Restructuring of Certain Receivables and Amending Certain Laws (“Law No. 7440”), published in the Official Gazette dated 12 March 2023 and No. 32130, significant and new tax regulations regarding debt push down financing structure for merger transactions are introduced...
Provisional Article 32 was added to Banking Law numbered 5411 (“BL”) through Article 17 of the Law No. 7186 on Amendments to the Income Tax Law and Certain Laws ("Law No. 7186") in the Official Gazette on 19.07.2019. This law enables companies that are experiencing financial difficulties, but which are...
Law No. 7420 on the Amendment of Income Tax Law and Certain Laws and Decrees (“Law No. 7420“) which was published in the Official Gazette dated 09.11.2022 introduced important amendments and regulations in the tax legislation. The addition of Article 32/B, entitled "Taxation in Capital Decrease" to...
Free Zones are zones that are established to promote export-oriented investment and production, accelerate foreign direct investment and technology access, direct enterprises towards export, and develop international trade. There are many tax advantages provided to taxpayers operating in...
Through the promulgation of Law No. 7394 on the Amendments of Treasury-Owned Immovable Property Valuation and the Value Added Tax Law and on the Amendments of Certain Other Laws and Decrees, published in the Official Gazette dated 15 April 2022 and No. 31810, significant amendments...
In recent years, many new business models have emerged and traditional business models have changed greatly, within the increasing digitalization in the economy. Along with said change, challenges arose for taxing the international business income of...
Through the promulgation of the Law No. 7351, published in the Official Gazette dated 22.01.2022 and no. 31727, essential amendments are introduced to Turkish tax legislation. Apart from the tax amendments, a new provision has been added to...
Social media has emerged with the development of the digital world and internet technology and has greatly influenced the world today. One of the main categories of actors in social media is social media content producers. These people earn through social networks in...
Law No. 7326 on the Restructuring of Certain Receivables and Amendments to Certain Laws ("Law No. 7326") entered into force by being published in the Official Gazette dated 9 June 2021. In Law No. 7326, provisions regarding (i) the restructuring of finalized tax receivables, (ii) tax receivables that are not...
The 1990’s hold significant importance by means of the developments that took place in the global economy. During the transition to the second half of the 1900’s, the Federal Reserve increased interest rates, and the hot money flow changed its direction from East Asian countries to the West...